This note was prepared in reply to the following question from Aykut Saygılı, concerning the note published under the title Interest Rates:
“Professor, in the note you state that the Turkish lira yield curve is inverted (as maturity lengthens, the yield falls from about 41 per cent to 36.6 per cent), whereas the US Treasury curve slopes upward (2-year 4.79 per cent, 10-year 5.10 per cent). For the NPV of a multi-year project financed with a dollar loan (mining projects, for example), which curve should we use? Should we discount in dollars, using the US curve together with a country-risk premium and a company margin, or in lira, by adding an exchange-rate expectation to the TL curve? And should we apply a single rate to all cash flows, or discount each year’s cash flow at the rate that corresponds to its maturity?”
Answers and explanations
For a mining project whose selling price is largely tied to the dollar, I prefer to set up the net present value (NPV) calculation in dollars. I use the US Treasury curve to determine the risk-free rate in dollars, and I discount the project cash flows at a dollar cost of capital that reflects the project’s risk. After calculating the economic value of the investment, I examine separately in which years the interest and principal payments on the dollar loan can be met.
1. Does the use of a dollar loan determine the currency of the valuation?
When choosing the currency of a valuation, I first look at the currency to which revenues and costs are economically tied. If, for example, the selling price of the mineral is set in dollars on the international market, a substantial part of revenue is economically dollar-linked even if the invoice is issued in lira. Wages, local services and some operating costs, by contrast, may be incurred in lira. Imported equipment and spare parts may be priced in dollars or euros.
When I build a financial model in dollars, I estimate lira costs by asking first: How many lira will this cost be next year? Personnel costs, for example, I project from wage increases, and local service costs from the price adjustments in the contracts. I then move to the second question: In the period when I pay this lira cost, how many dollars will that amount correspond to? I divide the lira amount I have forecast by the exchange rate I expect for the payment period, that is, by the rate that shows how many lira one dollar is worth.
Suppose a mining operation’s annual personnel cost is 6 million lira today and the exchange rate is 50 TL per dollar. The dollar equivalent of that cost today is 120,000 dollars. Assume that next year the personnel cost rises by 30 per cent in lira and the dollar rate rises by 20 per cent.
| Item | Today | Next year |
|---|---|---|
| Personnel cost | 6,000,000 TL | 7,800,000 TL |
| Lira value of one dollar | 50 TL | 60 TL |
| Dollar equivalent of personnel cost | 120,000 USD | 130,000 USD |
A rise in the rate from 50 lira to 60 lira allows the operation to cover more lira cost with each dollar it holds. Today, for example, 120,000 dollars covers 6 million lira of personnel cost; next year the same 120,000 dollars covers 7.2 million lira. Personnel cost, however, has risen to 7.8 million lira. Covering the remaining 600,000 lira at 60 TL per dollar requires another 10,000 dollars. Personnel cost therefore rises in dollar terms from 120,000 dollars to 130,000 dollars. That is an increase of about 8.3 per cent.
In the percentage calculation, the factor for a 30 per cent rise in the lira cost is 1.30, and the factor for a 20 per cent rise in the exchange rate is 1.20. Because the dollar cost is found by dividing the lira amount by the exchange rate, the growth factors are divided as well:
Increase in the cost in dollars = [(1.30 ÷ 1.20) − 1] = 8.3 per cent
The effect on the profit margin can be seen with the same example. Assume that annual sales revenue is 1 million dollars in both years. Personnel cost as a share of sales rises from 12 per cent to 13 per cent. If other costs are unchanged in dollars, the operating margin falls by 1 percentage point.
When I build a mining-project model in dollars, I therefore look at the pace of increase in lira costs and the pace of increase in the exchange rate together. If lira costs rise faster than the exchange rate, the cost in dollars increases. If the two rise at the same rate, the dollar equivalent of the cost stays constant. If the exchange rate rises faster, the dollar equivalent of the cost falls. Even in a project whose selling price is tied to the dollar, this relationship between local costs and the exchange rate can change the project’s profitability in dollars.
2. How are the US Treasury yield, the country-risk premium and the company margin used?
Depending on how the components are defined, this sum can be used to estimate the cost of borrowing in dollars. The cost of borrowing is one component of the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) calculated for the project. After capital expenditure, working capital and operating taxes have been taken into account, I discount project free cash flow — computed before interest and principal payments — at a rate that reflects the return required by both lenders and equity investors.
- For the cost of equity I start from the risk-free rate in dollars. I take account of the project’s market risk and of its exposure to country risk arising from operating in Türkiye. The fact that sales are tied to the dollar does not remove the risks that come from licensing, regulation and local operating conditions.
- For the cost of debt I use the cost of the dollar financing the project can actually obtain. If, for example, the loan is priced at SOFR plus a bank margin, the contractual reference rate and margin determine the cash interest payments. If the loan offer already prices country risk, adding the same premium again to the cost of debt counts that risk twice. In the WACC I take the after-tax effect of the cost of debt to the extent that the interest deduction can be used.
Purely as an illustration, if the target financing mix is 40 per cent debt and 60 per cent equity, the after-tax dollar cost of debt is 7 per cent and the dollar cost of equity is 15 per cent, the dollar WACC is 11.8 per cent. In this example, 7 per cent is the cost of debt, and 11.8 per cent is the cost of capital used to discount project cash flows before debt service.
3. Can the project be valued in lira using an exchange-rate expectation?
A valuation in lira is also possible. Dollar revenues and costs are converted into lira at the exchange-rate assumptions for the relevant periods, and project cash flows are discounted at a cost of capital that is stated in lira and reflects the same project risk. The exchange-rate assumption serves to translate future cash flows from one currency into the other. The lira and dollar discount rates must be consistent with that exchange-rate path. The Turkish Treasury yields in the earlier note show the term structure of lira interest rates. The project-specific cost of capital is calculated separately.
Take a simple example. Assume that the spot rate is 50 TL per dollar and that the rate used in the model for the end of one year is 60 TL per dollar. 100 dollars received in one year is 6,000 lira in the model. If the one-year dollar discount rate is 10 per cent, the lira discount rate that produces the same present value under this exchange-rate assumption is 32 per cent [(1.10 × 1.20) − 1].
- Dollar calculation: 100 ÷ 1.10 = 90.91 dollars.
- Lira calculation: 6,000 ÷ 1.32 = 4,545.45 lira. At today’s exchange rate that amount is again 90.91 dollars.
In this example, 32 per cent is the discount rate consistent with the assumed exchange-rate path. When the same project is valued in two currencies and the results, translated at the spot rate, diverge, I first check the assumptions behind the exchange-rate path, the cost increases and the discount rates.
4. A single rate, or discounting by maturity?
A single WACC is a reasonable practice when project risk and the target debt–equity mix are relatively stable over time. If, for example, an 11.8 per cent WACC is used for every year, the second year’s cash flow is divided by (1.118)2 and the tenth year’s cash flow by (1.118)10. Even with a single rate, each cash flow is discounted for its own maturity.
When we want the term structure of interest rates to appear explicitly in the model, we use, for each cash flow, a discount factor that runs from today to the date of that cash flow. For the cash flow in year five, the risk-free building block is the five-year spot rate, that is, the zero-coupon rate corresponding to a single payment between today and the end of year five. The two-, five- and ten-year Treasury yields in the earlier note can be used to show the shape of the curve. Valuing by maturity from those yields requires the related spot discount factors, and a consistent reflection of project risk in those factors.
In a mining project I also keep separate the term structure of interest rates and the way project risk changes over time. The first is about the difference between two-year and ten-year risk-free rates. The second is about the difference in risk across construction, the start of production and steady production. A one-year delay in the start of production, for example, I examine by pushing sales revenue out and putting the additional investment and operating costs into the model. That shows in which year, and by how much, the delay creates a cash shortfall.
In this mining example, my practice is as follows. If the selling price is tied to the dollar, I calculate project NPV in dollars. I first build the base case with a single dollar WACC that reflects project risk. If project value rests largely on cash flows in distant years, I look at how much the result changes when maturity-matched discount factors are used. I then enter the interest and principal schedule of the dollar loan on the same operating forecasts, and I measure whether cash available for debt service is sufficient in each payment period. A mining investment can create value over its life and still be unable to meet a loan instalment in a year when production is delayed. That is the distinction I want to see when investment and financing decisions are considered together.
Comments
Comments are held for moderation and appear here only after approval. No account is required to comment.